VA Refinance vs Conventional Refinance
The Short Answer
For a borrower eligible for both, a VA refinance is usually the cheaper option because VA loans carry no monthly mortgage insurance at any loan-to-value ratio and allow access to a larger share of home equity on a cash-out. Conventional refinancing wins in a narrower set of cases: when you want to refinance a second home or investment property, when your equity position is strong enough that a conventional loan avoids the VA funding fee, or when you want to remove existing conventional mortgage insurance without restarting a full VA loan.
VA vs Conventional Refinance Requirements
Program rules only. We do not post rates, because they change daily.
| Requirement | Detail |
|---|---|
| Monthly mortgage insurance | VA: none. Conventional: required above 80% LTV |
| One-time fee | VA funding fee vs no VA fee on conventional |
| Cash-out equity access | VA allows a higher share of value |
| Property types | VA: primary residence only. Conventional: second homes and rentals too |
| Streamline option | VA IRRRL is faster than conventional rate-and-term |
| Credit flexibility | VA underwriting adds a residual income test |
The mortgage insurance question decides most files
Conventional loans above 80% loan-to-value require private mortgage insurance, a monthly charge that exists purely to protect the lender. VA loans never carry it, at any loan-to-value ratio, including on a cash-out. For a borrower who is refinancing with limited equity, that single difference usually settles the comparison before anything else is considered.
The counterweight is the VA funding fee — a one-time charge rather than a recurring one. If you have substantial equity, are not VA-disability exempt, and would land under 80% loan-to-value on a conventional refinance, the math can flip. Run both.
Where conventional genuinely wins
The VA program requires the property to be your primary residence. If you are refinancing a rental you kept after a PCS, or a second home, conventional is the only option on the table for a rate-and-term or cash-out refinance.
Conventional also has no funding fee at all. A veteran with 30% equity, no disability exemption, and no mortgage insurance requirement may find a conventional refinance costs less in total than the VA funding fee would.
Speed is not close
If your existing loan is already a VA loan and you only want a lower rate, the IRRRL has no conventional equivalent. No appraisal, no income documents, a reduced funding fee. The conventional rate-and-term refinance requires full documentation and, in most cases, an appraisal.
How we run the comparison
We price both, put the total cost over your realistic holding period side by side, and tell you which one is cheaper. We are a VA-focused lender and we still send people to conventional when it wins. Your holding horizon matters more than the headline rate in most of these decisions.
Is This The Right Move?
This fits you if
- You are eligible for both programs and want the total-cost comparison rather than a rate quote.
- You are paying conventional PMI and want to know whether VA eliminates it cheaply.
- You have an existing VA loan and want to know whether an IRRRL or a conventional refinance is better.
- You receive VA disability compensation, which removes the funding fee from the equation.
Look elsewhere if
- You are refinancing an investment property or second home — VA does not allow it.
- You are not VA-eligible, in which case conventional or FHA is the comparison to run.
VA vs Conventional Refinance Questions
Quick Answer
No. It usually is, because VA carries no monthly mortgage insurance, but a borrower with substantial equity who would avoid PMI on a conventional loan may pay less in total by skipping the VA funding fee. The comparison depends on your equity, your disability exemption status, and how long you will hold the loan.
Other Refinance Options
Run The Numbers Before You Commit
We will show you the total cost side by side and tell you plainly if refinancing is not worth it.
Proudly Serving Military Families Since 2019